wotw entry comments please



V2

Yeah, i really like this manip wallpaper, the background is nice and not empty. the textures on the stock are nice and nice texture colours. The stock is good the effect on it I like it (I cant do manips lol). The idea of the text going down is nice but the choice of font I dont think is not nice imo. The cliiping mask is good thats one of the best parts. I like the reflects of the wallpaper, thats really nice!, I like this wall mate, Overal its nice but just the font needs changing imo

Really nice mate..
the textures are class, lighting is good,
some things to improve on are the text.. which i dont really like mate imo and the plainess of the left side of the bg

but overall good job mate and good luck in wotw!

It's quite nice, mate, good render effects, really liking them nice use of textures. Blending of the stock is nice. Bg is quite nice, it fits well with the wp. The pattern thing should be removed though imo. Text isn't so good, it should be changed, a simple one probably would look nicer. Reflection is fine. KIU!

Nice v2, mate, great to see you changed the text to a better one and it's nice you made the colors a little more orange. KIU!

v2

Nice wall mate.
The pattern in the bg looks nice and the bg color looks nice.
The stock looks great and the colors look good. The textures on the stock looks good. The text is nice, but IMO too small. I think you should make the text bigger and find another position for the text.
You can maybe place it on the left side, because the leftside looks a bit empty.
The reflection looks nice

v2 is the best.

Colors are nice and so is lightning.
Effects are really good and fit each other well. I miss some effects near his leags though.
The different fonts looks very good, and the colors fit the stock nicely.
Background is ok, but needs some improvements. Think the left side is too empty. Make the background of the stock fill out more of the background. You could also add a big text in the left side. The effects on the background looks good, but think you should put the opacity down a bit.
Mirror image looks fit and suit the wallpaper nicely.

Nice work mate, hope too see a v3, really liked this version.

wow great wall.... the text is good.... the lightning works are great...the bg is nice.. the textures are also nice..

great effects on render, but i dont like the text in both.I think the lightining and colours are great in both, but i prefer v2. Gerrard is a bit chubby haha

great wall, macky.

I like V1 the best, just the text is too much there try to blend it a bit more in with the total picture/artwork
Effects are good, colors and placing aswell.

I prfer the v2 mate. Colours are very nice. Effects are ok but i think you add more effects on gerrard not a lot but more effects. Lights are nice. I prefer the v2 because the text is better. The first text in the v1 don't fit with the wall. The second is better. Good job

v1 is nicer David
Font is amazing, I like it very much.
Render is cool, effekts are good. Bg is good, its the mittle of empty and full. Great Wallpaper. I hope I see more from you Wallies.

nice one mate, background is nice, effects are good and the text is ok. good job macky. kiu

nvm already repled here

v2 the best.
Any way i like so much the colours, the lights and the effects.
I do not find mistakes particular.
Maybe I would have enlarged the text.

v2 is much better and its now my wallpaper
but like everyone else said the text didnt really look good on v1,
like the general glow around the render and the floral bg that doesnt make it too blank